• Home
  • About
  • Publications
  • Links
    • Drilling and Fracking
    • Resources
    • Stuff I Like
    • TX Progressive Alliance
  • Must See Videos
  • PSYOPS
  • Shale Survival
    • Before drilling starts
    • Tools
    • Medical
  • FAQ
  • Contact Me

Texas Sharon's Bluedaze

Fracking News

TX HB 3328 is one of the nation’s weakest hydraulic fracture disclosure bills

March 25, 2011 By TXsharon

In today’s article in the Texas Tribune, Texas Could Require Disclosure of Drilling Chemicals, Scott Anderson, EDF, made some interesting claims about HB 3328, the hydraulic fracturing disclosure that is not so much about disclosure.

E.D.F. believes that passage of this bill would create the nation’s strongest disclosure system,” said Scott Anderson

He also said:

Federal legislation introduced in Congress would require disclosure of fracking chemicals. But Mr. Anderson, of the Environmental Defense Fund, said the Texas legislation is stronger than those proposals

Hang on a minute! I blogged about this bill on Wednesday and said the bill is inadequate, which it is. I’m not the only one who noticed that real disclosure is missing from this bill. Some impacted folks didn’t like it one bit.

So, I sent a letter to the Tribune, and I hope they will print it because this is damn important.

EDF believes that passage of Rep Keffer’s H.B. 3328 would create the nation’s strongest disclosure system.

In fact, H.B. 3328 allows industry to claim transparency without being transparent.

That’s because Keffer would allow industry to broadly claim many of their hydraulic fracturing toxics as “trade secrets.” Adding insult to injury, water users and landowners would be unable to challenge these industry “secret” claims.

In short, the trade secrecy provisions would contravene the ostensible purpose of the bill — informing the public about potential risks from drilling toxics.

Even Wyoming is doing better than that for landowners and water users. In Wyoming, the industry trade secrecy claims are left to the discretion of the regulator. So they’re subject to appeal and petition just like any other action of the agency.

H.B. 3328 may originate intending to aid the cause of disclosure, but in the end what it really does is enshrine in Texas state law the drilling industry’s penchant for secrecy.

Sharon Wilson

About Sharon Wilson

Sharon Wilson is considered a leading citizen expert on the impacts of shale oil and gas extraction. She is the go-to person whether it’s top EPA officials from D.C., national and international news networks, or residents facing the shock of eminent domain and the devastating environmental effects of natural gas development in their backyards.

  • Mail
  • |
  • Web
  • |
  • More Posts(5116)

Filed Under: hydraulic fracturing

Comments

  1. Anonymous says

    March 26, 2011 at 9:06 pm

    If the industry "is pleased," as the Texas Tribune article points out, then it's a certainty that "industry" wrote the bill. It's also clear that the Texas Tribune didn't even take the time to interview North Texas Democrats who could have provided a totally different perspective on all of it. I'm glad they quoted you, Sharon. The rest of it is very disappointing.

  2. Anonymous says

    March 27, 2011 at 2:51 am

    Anybody remember where the seed money for The Texas Tribune came from?

    T. Boone Pickens.

  3. Anonymous says

    March 27, 2011 at 5:43 pm

    Anon: Not a fair implication you are suggesting. TX Tribune needs to be educated like everyone else on this issue. Keep pushing cause they are willing to listen.

  4. TXsharon says

    March 27, 2011 at 6:27 pm

    Anon 12:43, I completely agree! This is not the Tribune's fault!!! The reporter has done a FINE job of reporting on the gas drilling issues. If you want to blame someone, blame me for not being clear when I spoke with her. Or better yet, blame the folks who wrote the bill and made misleading statements about it.

Stalk TXsharon

Recent Posts

  • Register for the worldwide premier of Uncovering the Permian Climate Bomb
  • Update: Chris Faulkner > IT Guy > Frack Master > Felon
  • French Energy Giant Total Declares War on Texas Toddlers
  • Hydrocarbon odors during oil and gas drilling
  • MSNBC and TXsharon in the Texas fracking zone
  • Blowout: Inside America’s Energy Gamble

Like Earthworks on Facebook

Categories

Archives

All work © Sharon Wilson. No works may be shared copied in full without permission. Bluedaze: Drilling Reform. Site Design by Sumy Designs. Powered by those who advocate for a safe and healthy environment.